Consumers Bank Locations

Carrollton Office


1017 Canton Road NW
Carrollton, OH 44615


Phone: (330) 627-3523
Fax: (330) 627-5391

Lobby Hours

Mon - Thurs: 9am - 5pm
Fri: 9am - 6pm
Sat: 9am – 12pm

Drive-Thru Hours

Mon - Thurs: 9am - 5pm
Fri: 9am - 6pm
Sat: 9am - 12pm

 ATM available

Missy Naylor


Branch Relationship Manager

Missy is the Carrollton Branch Relationship Manager and leads her team that assists the branch’s clients with all their financial needs. As the face of the branch, Missy is the bank’s representative at fundraisers and local events held by organizations that the bank supports including the Carroll County Chamber of Commerce, Carroll County Fair, Big Brothers/Big Sisters, and others.

Michele Catlett


Commercial Lender

Michele Catlett is the Carrollton branch's Business Lender, assisting local businesses grow by financing commercial loans and lines of credit. She is an active participant in Big Brothers and Big Sisters, Vice President of the Community Improvement Corporation, and is a board member of Carroll County Chamber of Commerce where she supports local events and fundraisers.

Anthony Mattioli


Mortgage Originator
NMLS: 758265

Bev Newell, a former manager of the Carrollton branch, is now the Mortgage Originator for Carrollton’s clients seeking mortgage financing. Bev started the annual Chili Cookoff to raise funds for Big Brothers/Big Sisters over 15 years ago which has raised thousands of dollars and continues to be popular with local clients and neighbors. She is a past board member of Carroll County Coats for Kids which has provided coats, hats, and gloves to the children in Carroll County for the past 10 years. Bev is also an active member of the Carroll County Chamber of Commerce.

Nick Mascitti


Mortgage Originator
NMLS: 732979

Sarah Grubbs


Agricultural Loan Officer

Sarah Grubbs is the Agricultural Lender for the bank based in the Carrollton office. In addition to assisting farmers with their lending needs, Sarah is the bank’s buyer at the Carroll County Fair. Each year Sarah makes purchases to support local kids who have raised livestock for the Junior Fair.

*Notice: Clicking on the links in the map above will take you directly to Google Maps and result in you leaving the bank's website.

MoneyPass ATMs

Money PassThe MoneyPass network offers 32,000 in-network surcharge-free ATMs coast to coast located where you live, work and travel.

This locator will help you find the most convenient ATM location to use your MoneyPass card surcharge-free.

Learn more about MoneyPass